7 out of 5 stars. My family of 6 loves eating here! The food is always amazing, and the decor is pretty dope. My personal favorites are the cheese bread, the tiger balls (think gooey cinnamon rolls on steroids!), the Bruschetta and the house salad! I don't know where they get their ingredients for the house salad but I always get compliments at work from people passing by asking where the "yummy looking" salad came from. My husband's favorites are the breadsticks and hot wings. My sons all love the buffalo wings and the hot ham and cheese! Baseball lover's delight! The arcade is cool too!

The best people and pizza.

Friendly staff great pizza cozy bar one side family eating on the other side

Loved it!! First impression didn't disappoint, very nicely decorated with sport memorabilia everywhere, pictures covering walls, many things to keep ur eyes entertained.. The food was not like any "I can get this anywhere" but has its own signature, thought out flavors... Very delicious, fresh and gives u that old fashioned, home made, family comfort feel. The staff were welcoming, polite and professional. In all a place to make u feel comfortable to come hang out with friends and family. Added bonus was to see the owner working hard along side the others.. Its shows the dedication and passion that goes into what makes it so great. Highly recommended!!!

Best pizza. In Evansville. hands down. 😋😋

Wings were very good as was the bbq Strom. The sausage bread appetizer was awesome!

Absolutely the best pizza, stroms, bread sticks. I have eaten

Food and service is great. Might even say this is the best slice in town

I rarely write reviews, shame on me, but I had to share this. I went to Casey’s Dugout last night to pick up a to-go order for my wife. After I ordered, Casey actually came up to personally thank me for coming in. Then, when the young woman brought out the food, she mentioned they had thrown in some cheese bread on the house. I know how tight margins are for local businesses right now, so that kind of generosity really stands out. It was so, so kind. You have a customer for life!

Everything we have tried from Casey’s Dugout has been delicious! The atmosphere in the restaurant is delightful. Top-notch service. Highly recommend!